Luxury Vacation Rentals in New Shoreham

Never book a bad vacation home again. Every Wander comes with hotel-grade amenities, inspiring views, pristine cleaning and 24/7 concierge service.

We found 5 vacation rentals – enter your dates for availability.

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Shoreham

Tangney Cottage

4 bedrooms•1.5 baths

•

~$170 less than other sites

Sterling Main House

3 bedrooms•1.5 baths

•

~$185 less than other sites

Sterling House

5 bedrooms•3.5 baths

•

~$270 less than other sites

Luxury

Cottage Farm

6 bedrooms•4 baths

•

New

~$200 less than other sites

Blackberry Meadow

3 bedrooms•2.5 baths

Welcome to New Shoreham

Set your sights on a refined island escape with Wander's luxury vacation rentals in New Shoreham. Here, the polish of a five-star stay meets the privacy of a beautifully designed home, so every moment feels effortless.

Each residence is handpicked for inspiring Atlantic views, airy indoor-outdoor living, and serene bedrooms dressed in premium linens. Expect chef-ready kitchens, spa-like baths, dedicated workspaces with ultra fast WiFi, and thoughtful smart-home touches. Every stay is impeccably cleaned and supported by 24/7 concierge service.

Book with confidence knowing every home looks exactly like the photos and lives even better. For work, celebration, or simple reset, your Block Island retreat awaits.

Available soon in New Shoreham

Sterling Main House

3 bedrooms•1.5 baths

•

~$185 less than other sites

Sterling House

5 bedrooms•3.5 baths

•

~$270 less than other sites

Luxury

Cottage Farm

6 bedrooms•4 baths

•

New

~$200 less than other sites

Featured vacation rentals in New Shoreham

Sterling House

5 bedrooms•3.5 baths

•

~$270 less than other sites

Highlights in New Shoreham

Discover Block Island's pristine beaches, dramatic clay cliffs, and historic lighthouses in this charming, laid-back New England island escape.

Mohegan Bluffs

Southeast Lighthouse

North Lighthouse

Crescent Beach

Great Salt Pond

Clayhead Nature Trail

IT'S A VACATION HOME, BUT BETTER

The Wander difference

Wander is different because we combine the quality of a luxury hotel with the comfort of a private vacation home. Your best trip ever is just a few clicks away.

Only the best homes

We’ll never not look like the pictures. Every Wander is beautiful and expertly operated, so you can leave any stress at the door.

Hotel-grade amenities

We’ll never leave you with nothing to do. From ultra fast WiFi to gyms and pools, our homes make it easy to blend work and play.

24/7 concierge service

We’ll never leave you hanging. Our chat-based Concierge is always available to help – from trip questions to special requests.

Inspiring and stunning views

We’ll never leave you uninspired. Every Wander has stunning views to refresh and inspire your soul. Adventure awaits.

Meticulous cleaning

We’ll never have you check in to a dirty house. Our cleaning teams are meticulous, and there are no chores at checkout.

Safety and security

We’ll never pass you off to a stranger. Every Wander location meets our industry-leading safety standards to give you peace of mind.

All homes in New Shoreham

Tangney Cottage

4 bedrooms•1.5 baths

•

~$170 less than other sites

Sterling Main House

3 bedrooms•1.5 baths

•

~$185 less than other sites

Sterling House

5 bedrooms•3.5 baths

•

~$270 less than other sites

Luxury

Cottage Farm

6 bedrooms•4 baths

•

New

~$200 less than other sites

Blackberry Meadow

3 bedrooms•2.5 baths

View all homes

Most popular amenities for vacation rentals in New Shoreham

Other popular amenities & vacation types in New Shoreham

Family vacation rentals in New Shoreham

Pet-friendly vacation rentals in New Shoreham

Large group vacation rentals in New Shoreham

Discover more of New Shoreham

New Shoreham unfolds across Block Island with wild bluffs, sweeping beaches, and a timeless maritime pulse. Walk the rim of Mohegan Bluffs to feel the Atlantic's power, then trace stone-walled lanes to meadows bright with summer blooms. Historic lighthouses anchor the horizon while the Great Salt Pond buzzes with sails and skiffs.

Days stretch long here. Sunrise gilds the open ocean, sunset melts over Block Island Sound, and stars appear in striking clarity thanks to low light pollution. Summer hums with energy, yet spring and fall reveal quieter trails and migrating birds. Frequent ferries and a convenient island airport make arrivals easy.

This is why Wander's luxury vacation rentals in New Shoreham are the perfect choice, whether you are traveling for work or leisure.

FAQs: Vacation Rentals in New Shoreham

Why should I book a Wander in New Shoreham over other vacation rentals?

Wander offers a level of consistency and quality you won’t find with most vacation rentals.

Every home in New Shoreham delivers the quality of a luxury hotel, paired with the comfort and space of a private vacation home. You get hotel-grade amenities, meticulous cleaning, stunning views, and 24/7 concierge support in every stay. Why would you want to stay anywhere else?

Which are Wander’s most popular vacation rentals in New Shoreham?

Some of our most popular vacation rentals in New Shoreham include Tangney Cottage, Sterling Main House, and Sterling House. Guests love the quality of a luxury hotel, the comfort of a private vacation home, and the consistently exceptional experience Wander is known for. Explore the full collection to find the perfect home for your next stay.

How many different vacation rentals does Wander have available in New Shoreham?

Wander offers 5 vacation rentals in New Shoreham, each carefully designed and expertly operated. Browse the full collection to see what’s available for your trip.

What time is check-in and check-out at Wander’s vacation rentals in New Shoreham?

You can check-in to Wander vacation rentals in New Shoreham after 4.00pm and check-out before 10.00am.

Do Wander’s vacation rentals in New Shoreham have WiFi access?

Yes. Every Wander home in New Shoreham has ultra fast, reliable WiFi so you can stay connected throughout your stay.

What is Wander’s cancellation policy?

You can cancel your reservation within 24 hours of booking for a full refund.

For stays of less than 15 nights, you can cancel or reschedule up to 14 days before check-in for a full refund. For stays of 15 nights or longer, the cancellation window is 60 days.

For some homes, a 30-day deadline applies; this will be clearly shown before you book.